10 Sports Moments I Still Wish Never Happened

8–13 minutes

UPDATE: I went with the memories that I can relate to most. Joe Carter is my first true sports memory. If it never happened, would I be the scarred bitter adult I am today?

Sure, there have been bad outcomes to games or our teams have made bad decisions, but sometimes all of it boils down to a single moment where everything went wrong all at once. These are the moments we wished never happened. You are probably thinking of one right now. Let’s get into it…

Super Bowl 57 – Defensive Holding on James Bradberry

This is THE one. With the score tied at 35 with 1:54 seconds to go the Chiefs had driven all the way down to the Eagles 15 yard line. The Eagles had just used their 2nd timeout and one more stop would allow for a field goal, but a solid 90 seconds to try to win the Super Bowl. The Chiefs defense had been completely unable to contain Jalen Hurts thus far and we were going to be in for a great finished. Patrick Mahomes over threw JuJu Smith-Schuster by a lot and it looked like we were going to have our ending. There was a flag though. James Bradberry got a hand on JuJu and with Patrick Mahomes losing his mind, they gave it to him. By the letter of the law, it was a penalty, Bradberry admitted as much. But at that moment in that situation, that call is rarely made. It changed everything. Now the Chiefs would be able to run the clock down to the final seconds to kick the winner thanks to a ticky-tack call.

We don’t know what would have happened. Maybe the Chiefs stop the Eagles and nothing is any different. Maybe the Eagles drive down and we go to overtime. Just maybe the Eagles drive to the 1 with 3 seconds to go and opt for a Super Bowl winning Tush Push instead of the 3 points. For an incredible game, it’s a shame we didn’t get the chance at the incredible ending that might have been.

Cristopher Sanchez “BALL”

With the Phillies up 1-0 in the 7th inning of Game 4 of the 2025 NLDS and the Dodgers up 2-1 in the series, Cristopher Sanchez was cruising. He was at 88 pitches on 4 hits and no walks with Alex Call at the plate. On a 2-2 count, Sanchez painted a 97 mph strike 3 on the inside part of the box. This should have brought Kike Hernandez to the plate with 2 outs and the bases empty. Instead, the umpire called it ball 3 and Sanchez was beside himself. Call walked on the next pitch and Hernandez singled on a full count next. 3 batters later, the Dodgers tied the game and won in 11 on the walk off Orion Kerkering error. Sure, I wish Kerkering never threw that ball away, but in a game that ended 2-1, the blown call that tied is what really kills me. The umpire even apologized to Sanchez after the game for blowing it. Had the ABS system been introduced a year earlier, this would not have happened.

Zack Wheeler Pulled In the 6th of World Series Game 6

This one could really be two. The worst hitter in the 2022 World Series, backup catcher Martin Maldonado, led off the 6th inning by leaning into a pitch from Wheeler. Had the umpires had the balls to call him out like they should have, everything changes. They called him safe though. Jose Altuve grounded out before Jeremy Pena singled to make it 1st and 3rd with Yordan Alvarez at the plate.

Had this been two months earlier, no problem with bringing in Jose Alvarado for a lefty on lefty matchup. By this point though, Alvarado was toast and everyone knew it. Despite Wheeler sitting at just 70 pitches and still looking great, manager Rob Thomson went to Alvarado and the rest is history. Alvarez took the 2-1 pitch over the fence, the Astros took a 3-1 lead, and the Phillies never threatened again to lose the series.

Kawhi Leonard Shot

I wasn’t upset. It was more of a full body numbing to combat the disbelief. Game 7, tied at 90, 4 seconds left, and Toronto had the ball. Kawhi Leonard took the inbound pass, drove to the right, got nowhere but deeper into the corner, and threw up a prayer over Joel Embiid. It’s not even like the ball hit the back of the rim and bounced in, it hit the front of the rim. Then it hit the front of the rim again and instead of bouncing backwards like Physics would normally dictate, it took a Lee Harvey Oswald level turn and went forward to the other side of the rim, bounced again, and dropped through the hoop. It’s not supposed to work like that.

I don’t know if the Sixers would have won the game in overtime, I don’t know if they would have won the championship, I don’t know if Jimmy Butler stays at that point, and I don’t know if anything would be any different. That shot still kills me though.

Phone Call Between Cutter Gauthier and Danny Briere

What happened? The Flyers have spoken briefly and defiantly about their falling out with Cutter Gauthier but the player has remained silent. There was a phone call between the two sides and something happened. Cutter was under the impression that he would join the team for the final month of the season. The team had a different idea. They never spoke again.

Now the Flyers find themselves in desperate need of a star and Cutter is one of the premier scorers in the league. He scored 41 times last year and currently leads the NHL at about a goal per game. Jamie Drysdale is having a fine season but he is never going to be on the same tier as Gauthier. It didn’t have to be like this.

Markelle Fultz… Whatever It Was

The Sixers traded up in the 2017 NBA Draft to select Markelle Fultz. As a 3-level scorer who could play defense and handle the ball, he was the perfect complement to the young nucleus of Joel Embiid and Ben Simmons. He was the missing piece. He came out to summer league and didn’t disappoint either. 3 months later he was a completely different player.

To this day, no one really knows what happened. Sometime between Summer League and the start of training camp, Fultz’s jump shot completely evaporated. There were rumors that he had a motorcycle accident while others say a relative forced him to change his form. Not only was the once pretty shot dead, it would never come back.

Fultz was eventually taken out of the lineup as doctors tried to find a medical reason for his issues. There would be several diagnoses, but nothing would ever really explain what happened. He was able to carve out a decently successful career in Orlando, but the Sixers essentially wasted the #1 pick and no one ever really figured out how it happened.

What Are You Doing Rob???

In the 2023 NLCS, the Phillies looked like a juggernaut. In Game 2 they kicked the crap out of the overmatched Diamondbacks 10-0 and went to Arizona thinking there would be no need to come back to Philadelphia except for the World Series. Game 3 was tied at 1 going into the ninth when Phillies manager Rob Thomson was forced to go to Craig Kimbrel.1 Kimbrel had been solid for most of the season, but by this point, everyone knew he was cooked (like Alvarado the year before). He went walk, single, fielder’s choice, walk, single: GAME OVER. Ok, fine, it’s still 2-1

The very next night, the Phillies held a 5-3 lead in the 8th. Thomson essentially went with a bullpen game this time by pulling Cristopher Sanchez in the 3rd inning after 38 pitches. Jeff Hoffman was up in the 3rd and 4th, Matt Strahm took the 5th, and Seranthony took the 6th. Greg Soto and Kerkering combined to pitch the 7th. This mismanagement surely meant they would go with Alvarado for another 2 inning outing, right? Afterall, it only took him 15 pitches the night before. Nope. Rob went back to Kimbrel. Double, out, HR (game tied), K, Single, HBP. Alvarado let up the game winning single after he mercifully replaced Kimbrel. I still don’t understand what Rob was thinking.

Tyrese Maxey Pull Up Against Boston

This is a much less obvious one, but it was a moment that I knew was bad the minute it happened even if it wasn’t really that big of a deal. In the 2023 NBA Playoffs, the Sixers took a 3-2 lead into Game 6 at home against the Celtics. After being down 10 in the 3rd quarter, the Sixers started to roll. With around 5 minutes to go in the 4th, they were up 2 with the ball. Instead of going to Embiid inside, Maxey missed a 3 he didn’t need to take. Harden missed a 3 the next time down and the game was effectively over. If he had made it, maybe we win. Instead, the Celtics went on a 14-3 run to close out the game. That was our chance.

Whatever Made Ruben Amaro Jr Think He Had to Trade Cliff Lee

The Phillies took a big swing at the 2009 trade deadline by trading for Cleveland ace Cliff Lee. Lee was phenomenal the rest of the season all the way through the World Series against the Yankees. The real target that year though had been Roy Halladay. Even Doc thought he was going to be a Phillie before it ended up being Lee instead. The courtship wasn’t over though.

That offseason, the Phillies re-engaged Toronto for their all everything pitcher and struck a deal. For some high end (at the time) prospects, Halladay would finally be a Phillie and join Cole Hamels in the rotation. Not Lee though. Despite Cliff still having a year of control at a very modest $9m, RAJ got it into his head that he couldn’t have both. Maybe it was the money, maybe it was the supposed dearth of prospects in the system, but the same day as the Halladay trade, Lee was sent to Seattle. None of the Mariners prospects panned out. Halladay had maybe his best season, but it was Lee for the Rangers pitching in the World Series that year. We could have had both (and eventually did the next year).

Ben Simmons Refusing to End Trea Young

After a post Kawhi Leonard drop off, the Sixers were back in 2021 and finished with the best record in the Eastern Conference. After the Hawks upset the Knicks in round 1 of the playoffs, Philadelphia had the easiest road possible to get to the Finals…and they blew it. It was a series of lost leads, missed opportunities, and simply fear. It ended what was once seen as something possibly very special.

With less than 4 minutes to go and the Hawks up 2 in Game 7, Ben Simmons received the ball under the basket and had only Trea Young and his fear of defense in front of him. The worst that could happen in this situation was for Simmons to not get fouled on what should have been a dunk so violent that Young would have either quit basketball on the spot or been unable because he was dead. Still, 2 points at least. Instead, Simmons passed to Matisse Thybulle who was fouled and missed one of his free throws.

The game wasn’t over yet, but Simmons’ career in Philadelphia was. There was no coming back from this and Simmons refused to play for the Sixers ever again. I still can’t believe he didn’t dunk that ball.

—

Next time, we’ll talk about all the moments that went right, like when Jalen Carter saved the Eagles against the Rams and Julio Jones dropped that ball for the Falcons.

  1. I say forced, but he pulled Ranger Suarez early forcing Jeff Hoffman into the 6th, then Orion Kerkering got ZERO outs in the 7th forcing Jose Alvarado to get 6 outs. He could have gone to Seranthony Dominguez, but was probably waiting for a save situation. ↩︎

Leave a Reply