Let’s look back over the last 6 months of trades for Eagles GM Howie Roseman:

June 1, 2026: A.J. Brown traded to the New England Patriots for a 2028 1st Round Pick and a 2027 5th.

October 8, 2026: Cam Jurgens and a 2027 7th Round Pick traded to the Baltimore Ravens for a 2028 2nd Round Pick and a 2027 5th.

November 9, 2026: Jordan Davis traded to the Jacksonville Jaguars for a 2027 1st Round Pick and a 2029 2nd.

Are you kidding me??? That’s an incredible haul for three players no longer in the team’s long-term plans. AJ Brown had quit on the Eagles and wanted out. Cam Jurgens was maybe the worst lineman in the league and had lost his job to a 5th round pick at the time of the deal. And Jordan Davis had shown that last year’s breakout was not indicative of future success by crashing down to earth following his big extension. With Brown now having easily the worst season of his career, it’s hard not to say that each deal isn’t an A+ for the team.

Of course, there are people blaming Howie for the current state of the team. Here’s the thing, they aren’t wrong! When a team is 2-7, everyone shares the blame. Let’s look at the other moves Howie had his hands on.

Contracts

One of the trades not listed above was sending two 3rd round picks to the Minnesota Vikings for Jonathan Greenard. JG was then given a 4/$98m contract extension. Nothing has gone right since he arrived. You can blame it on injury, but it doesn’t negate the total lack of production: 1 sack in 6 games. One of the problems with the defense this year is a total lack of pressure and it starts with the ineffectiveness of Greenard.

Jordan Davis signed a 3/$78m extension, a huge move for a nose tackle following a breakout 2025. Then he cratered. It’s easy to see trading him as a failure but that completely negates the trade package he just brought in. After being drafted 13th overall and winning a Super Bowl, the Eagles paid approximately $20m in cash/$15m in dead cap to recoup another first round pick and a 2nd round pick. That’s the kind of return on investment that any team would sign up for, especially from a player not performing very well.

Then there are the contracts he didn’t sign. Reed Blankenship has been terrible after leaving for the Texans while Nakobe Dean looks like the lost heart of the defense. Though it didn’t make sense in a black and white look at the roster and the budget, both might be more valuable to the Eagles than anyone else.

People want to complain about the one year contracts like Arnold Ebiketie, Tariq Woolen, and Hollywood Brown. While none of those moves worked out, none are killers either.

Draft

Dating back to 2021, Howie was on an absolute heater drafting players:

Then 2025 happened. 5th round pick Drew Kendall might be the only starter out of that group next year thanks to Jihaad Campbell regressing and Andrew Mukuba simply never being very good. The jury is still out on 2026, but Markel Bell looks like a backup tackle and Eli Stowers can barely get on the field. Makai Lemon may be the only difference maker in two years and even that isn’t a given.

Hiring

By all accounts, Nick Sirianni was in charge of hiring his friend Kevin Patullo to be the offensive coordinator in 2025. He had just won the Super Bowl and was in need of a new contract himself. He had leverage. Following that disaster, the leverage was gone. That made Sean Mannion a Roseman hire. It hasn’t worked out at all. It’s pretty clear that even if Mannion has some good ideas, he is far too inexperienced to actually implement any of them effectively.

When Doug Pederson was fired, it came as a shock to everyone. He had just won the Super Bowl only 3 years prior. The reason was apparently that Doug was told to fire his friend Mike Groh and he refused. He lost his job for that insubordination. This is why Nick Sirianni has more job security than people realize. He has no problem with firing his friends, Kevin Patullo for example.

After previously losing a power struggle with Chip Kelly, Howie is very concerned with how much sway the head coach has with the Eagles. Hiring a new, experienced head coach possibly invites a similar situation into the Eagles front office. You have to wonder if that limits the pool of replacement candidates for either of the next batch of coordinators or possibly the next head coach.

He’s Still Howie

After the 2017 Super Bowl, the team got old quick and Carson Wentz never returned to his sophomore year MVP form. Instead of continuing to regress, Howie made the ballsy decision to draft Jalen Hurts, bottomed out in 2020, traded Wentz, then worked his magic with pre draft trades in ’21 and ’22. The team went from dead in the water to champions again.

We are now two years post Super Bowl with everyone coming to blame Howie for the recent mediocrity. Just when the future looks murky, he makes three trades to bring in two extra 1sts and 2nds while trimming future salary. Things have certainly not worked out as planned with Brown, Jurgens, and Davis but Howie alchemized them from dead weight to gold.

You can doubt Howie all you want and he’s certainly not perfect, but he is absolutely the best man for this job.

Leave a Reply