MLB held an expansion draft for the Rays and Diamondbacks on November 18, 1997. The Houston Astros had to make a decision about who to protect that day and decided to allow 23-year-old outfielder, Bobby Abreu, to hit the draft. After a cup of coffee in 1996 and then 59 games as a true rookie the following year, Houston just didn’t see the upside of their 1996 Minor League Player of the Year. The Rays selected him with the 6th overall pick.
Of course, that’s not where he ended up. 70 players were selected that day and only two of them, Hanley Frias and Aaron Ledesma, could be even moderately considered shortstops. The Rays convinced themselves that they needed to upgrade. That’s when they called up the Phillies.
Kevin Stocker is now patrolling the Phillies radio booth, but at the time he was holding down shortstop in Philadelphia. After debuting for the 1993 team, Stocker spent most of the next 4 seasons as the anchor of the infield. He was considered a solid defender, but his bat was just not very good. After debuting to an .824 OPS, he never got close to that kind of production again. By 1997, it was down to .690 with a decent amount of walks and not much in the way of power.

The Phillies thought they had their shortstop of the future ready to go in Desi Relaford but considering Darren Daulton was their primary right fielder that season (before getting traded to the Marlins) they were in desperate need of an outfielder. So, they answered the Rays call and agreed to send Stocker to the Rays for the recently drafted Abreu.
In 1998, Stocker hit .208 for the Devil Rays and was out of baseball 3 years later. Abreu stormed onto the scene with a .906 OPS and didn’t finish a single day of the season batting less than .300.1 He finished with 6.4 WAR, forming an unbelievable young 1-2 punch with fellow young breakout star Scott Rolen.
Abreu would get down ballot MVP votes the next season and would settle into regularly hitting .300+ with 40-ish doubles, well over 100 walks, and a .900+ OPS per season. For his career in Philadelphia, his stats were absurd on a per year basis:
| WAR | 2B | HR | RBI | SB | Walks | AVG | OBP | OPS | OPS+ |
| 5.6 | 40 | 23 | 94 | 29 | 107 | .305 | 415 | 933 | 141 |
By the 2006 trade deadline though, the Phillies weren’t doing so well at just 47-54. They had some young players like Ryan Howard and Chase Utley, but Abreu was expensive, had only one more season left on his contract, and was 32 years old. On July 30th, Abreu was traded to the Yankees along with Cory Lidle for a whole lot of nothing.
He would hit .330 for the Yankees and go to the playoffs for the first real time in his career (he went as a rookie with the Astros and had 3 at bats). There were a few more productive years in New York and then with the Angels before retiring in 2014 as a member of the NY Mets.
It’s almost preposterous to look at his numbers in Philadelphia and then remember that he was not very well liked by a contingent of the fanbase while he was here. Despite being about as dependable as possible, some fans saw him as aloof. His walks would be a godsend now, but at the time he was seen as a player who would rather keep the bat on his shoulder than get a big hit. He never showed much emotion and was therefore deemed to not be trying. He was very misunderstood.
Not helping the Bobby Abreu redemption tour was how the team responded to him leaving. The Phillies went 38-23 after he left and narrowly missed the playoffs. The following year they won the division and then won the World Series in 2008. Much of that credit is given to Abreu leaving and Jimmy Rollins filling the leadership void. Shane Victorino and then Jayson Werth manned right field and delivered at the plate and in the field (where Abreu was never good despite an outrageous gold glove award in 2005) in ways Abreu was no longer capable of doing. His was washed over by the accomplishments of those who came next.
Now Abreu finds himself on the Hall of Fame ballot for the 8th time. He took a 10% jump last year and is up to 30.8% of the needed 75% of the vote. He probably isn’t going to get in. Still, he was an amazing Phillie even if he’s still not getting the respect he deserves.
- I didn’t do all of the math, but it sure looks like there was never a single day as a Phillie where his cumulative average was less than .300. The lowest it got the next year was .308 ↩︎
Photo: This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. Created by Roger H. Rangel (edited and cropped)

Leave a Reply