The Phillies, the 40-Man, and the Minor Leagues

3–4 minutes

The deadline to protect minor league players who have been in the system for 5 years (under 19 when signing) or 4 years (over 19 when signing) was today. This means anyone eligible would need to be placed on the 40 man roster or risk being taken in the Rule 5 Draft. This is where things get strange. There might not be a Rule 5 Draft this year due to the coming lockout.

Rule 5

The Rule 5 rules are that teams have a draft to select these players then have to stick on the 26 man roster all season or be offered back to their original clubs. The Phillies ran this gambit with Noah Song a few years back and ultimately sent him back to the Red Sox. 20 years ago though they tried to offer Shane Victorino back to the Dodgers, but they didn’t want him. The last time there was a lockout, the Rule 5 Draft was cancelled.

Another interesting wrinkle about this year’s situation is that while MLB Players will be locked out, minor league players now have a separate union. They will NOT be locked out and can continue to have contact with their big clubs. If a player is on the 40 man, that means they are a part of the major league union and therefore not eligible to play in the minors during the lockout. Though Aiden Miller is not Rule 5 eligible, he will be able to play in the minors while the Phillies themselves are not able to play.

Protected

The only prospect the Phillies protected this season was last year’s breakout player Bryan Rincon. While it stinks that he will now not be eligible to practice with the Phillies, the team was obviously worried enough to protect him just in case there is a draft (it also would have been very suspicious if they did not).

Rincon broke into top 100 prospect lists by the end of this season looks to possibly be an infielder of the future for the Phillies. He is 22 and a switch hitting shortstop who will have no problem fielding the position long term apparently. He is a former 14th round pick in 2022.

Not Protected

The list is long and distinguished:

Escobar was the Rincon of the previous year, rocketing up prospect charts thanks to a hot hitting start to the year. He came back down to Earth this season. and finds himself not protected. Pan and Graves were surprisingly not protected since both will likely see time in the Phillies bullpen this season. Pan had missed extended time with both a broken pinky and Tommy John but finally finds himself healthy. Graves had specifically been mentioned by Dave Dombrowski as an option this season. Villacicencio is someone they like, but has almost no chance of sticking on a Major League roster all year. Anthony has hit at every level, walks a lot and doesn’t strike out much. The problem is that he is ultimately a first baseman with very little power.

Don’t Worry

As much as we kill Dave Dombrowski for various reasons, I cannot imagine he doesn’t officially know if there will be a Rule 5 Draft or not. Judging by the protection of just Rincon, he was probably told to protect someone but don’t make it too obvious. They went with Rincon. Had they not, it might have been seen as the fix being in, which the Owners do not want to do. It would then be used against them as not bargaining in good faith to unofficially cancel the draft before the lockout even begins. However, by not protecting the other guys, they can still stay in the system and be supervised and coached by the team.

For more about how the minor leagues work during the lockout, check out this article from Philly Baseball News

Leave a Reply